Argentina’s Supreme Court ruled unanimously on Thursday that two articles of President Milei’s 2023 decree, which let private health plans set their fees freely, are unconstitutional.
The Court said its decision means the Superintendency of Health Services, the national regulator, resumes the role a 2011 law gave it over private health plans, known in Argentina as prepagas. That role is to review their fees and approve increases that reflect changes in costs and a reasonable calculation of insurance risk.
The Court decided one member’s suit against the plan company Swiss Medical. It ordered no fee cut or refund and set no inflation cap: the justices set aside an appeals court’s order limiting her increases to inflation, and said the ruling offers no opinion on other parts of the decree.
According to the ruling, the suit began when the member said her fee rose 110% between December 2023 and February 2024, after the decree was issued, and that under the earlier rules the January 2024 increase would have been 6.26%. Swiss Medical and the national government both appealed to the Supreme Court after a federal appeals court in La Plata ruled for her.
The two articles were part of Decree 70/2023, a December 2023 deregulation decree that Milei issued as a decree of necessity and urgency (DNU), which takes effect without a vote in Congress. The justices found it gave no real reason for such urgency in health plans: it cited only a “crisis of the health system” and a need to “increase the competitiveness of the system”, which the ruling calls generic claims.
The Constitution, the justices wrote, does not permit “choosing at will between passing a law and imposing certain content more quickly by decree.” They applied the standard they restated in August, in a case known as Cencosud that struck down an article of a 2019 decree signed by then-President Mauricio Macri.
It is the first time the Supreme Court has declared any part of Decree 70 unconstitutional. Infobae reported that the Court has about 500 similar cases pending and that the reasoning could support members seeking refunds of increases already paid. The ruling cites a February 2025 government regulation that also says plans may set fees freely, but it decides only on the two articles of the 2023 decree.
The case now returns to the federal appeals court in La Plata, which must issue a new ruling in line with the Supreme Court’s decision.


