Investors behind the US$16.1 billion YPF judgment against Argentina have asked the US Supreme Court to revive it, filing a petition on Wednesday, September 30, to overturn a March appeals-court ruling that threw the award out.
The petitioners are Petersen Energía and Eton Park, the minority shareholders who sued over Argentina’s 2012 seizure of 51% of the oil company YPF, and whose case is funded by the litigation-finance firm Burford Capital. September 30 was the filing deadline, after lawyers won an extension from August 31, according to BAE Negocios. Former US Solicitor General Paul Clement filed the petition, according to Reuters.
On March 27, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York reversed Judge Loretta Preska’s 2023 judgment by a 2-1 vote. In an opinion by Judge Denny Chin, it held that the shareholders’ breach-of-contract claims are not cognizable under Argentina’s civil codes and its public law on expropriation. Judge Beth Robinson joined the majority, and Judge José Cabranes dissented. The full court declined in June to rehear the case, according to Los Andes and BAE Negocios. The ruling also undid the order that would have forced Argentina to hand over its YPF stake.
The petition asks two questions: whether a foreign state can invoke its own law to keep claims in its own courts despite jurisdiction under US sovereign-immunity law, and whether US courts should defer to a sovereign’s reading of its own law when it is first raised on appeal. The appeals court noted that Argentina took over YPF without the tender offer to minority shareholders that the company’s bylaws required, but held that Argentine law gave the shareholders no damages claim for it.
The odds are long. The Supreme Court receives 7,000 to 8,000 petitions a year and takes about 80, according to BAE Negocios. It declined to hear Argentina’s earlier appeal in 2019, leaving US jurisdiction over the case in place, a point Burford cites. Argentina’s Treasury Attorney’s Office told Argentine media it had expected the move and is preparing its defense, Perfil reported.
The stakes are large for Argentina. The Second Circuit noted the award equaled about 45% of the national budget for 2024; with interest it was about US$18 billion, according to Sullivan & Cromwell, the law firm that represented Argentina. The investors have also opened a second front: Burford-backed claimants launched an ICSID claim in September, at the World Bank’s arbitration forum, under the 1991 Argentina-Spain investment treaty, according to Perfil, and Global Arbitration Review reported it on September 17.
The Court has set no deadline to decide whether to take the case. If it declines, the Second Circuit’s reversal stands.
