A Buenos Aires court on Wednesday sentenced Justo Fernando Barrientos, 70, to life in prison for killing three lesbian women in a May 2024 fire, finding he acted out of hatred of their sexual orientation.
Oral Criminal and Correctional Court No. 5, made up of judges Adrián Pérez Lance, Juan Manuel Grangeat and Cinthia Oberlander, ruled unanimously, the prosecutors’ office said. It found him guilty of aggravated murder, committed with cruelty and treachery, out of hatred of the victims’ sexual orientation and by means that endanger the public. It applied the same charge, as an attempt, to a fourth woman who survived.
The women killed were Pamela Cobbas, Mercedes Roxana Figueroa and Andrea Amarante. Sofía Castro Riglos survived with burns to her arms, hands and face and spent almost a month in hospital. The four lived in one room of a boarding house in Barracas, a Buenos Aires neighborhood, as two couples, and Barrientos lived in the same building.
Prosecutors said he threw a flammable substance into the room where they were sleeping on the night of May 5 to 6, 2024. Cobbas died on May 6, Figueroa on May 8 and Amarante on May 12. Barrientos denied starting the fire, and his defense had asked for an acquittal on grounds of doubt. The court rejected that request. Before the sentence he told the court that he felt innocent.
The court did not apply an aggravating factor of gender-based violence that prosecutors and the victims’ lawyers had requested, and it rejected the reparation measures that Castro Riglos’s lawyer had asked for. The word lesbicide, which activists and much of the Argentine press use for the killing of women because they are lesbians, does not appear in the verdict.
Amnesty International Argentina said the verdict set a historic precedent but criticized the omission of gender-based violence. Lesbian-rights groups said it was the first time an Argentine court had applied the hate-crime aggravator to the killing of lesbian women.
The court will read its full reasons for the verdict on Feb. 19, 2027.



